Food & Drink
Top Pizzerias Churning Out Delicious Pies
Posted on May 9
Discover some local favorite pizza spots!
Tired of the same old frozen pizza every weekend? Spice up your dinner with these fan favorite pizzerias around Butler County. Choose from any of these 12 local shops and you won't go wrong.
Bruno’s Pizza
31 E High Street | Oxford, OH
Photo Credit : Bruno's Pizza
Bruno’s Pizza sells New York style by the slice. A Miami University staple, this is the perfect place to stop by when you are out and about wanting a quick bite late a night. Pair your pizza of choice with the Bruno Dough, deep fried dough sprinkled with garlic butter and parmesan cheese.
Our recommendation: Bruno’s Favorite – pepperoni, sausage, onion, green peppers, and mushrooms.
Calabria Pizza
1010 Main Street | Hamilton, OH
Photo Credit : Calabria Pizza
Calabria Pizza offers signature New York-style pizzas with homemade dough and Grande cheese. Popular menu items include meat lovers, bruschetta, and white pizza with ricotta and spinach, as well as calzones, salads, and a four-way pasta dish.
Our Recommendation: The Meat Lovers Pizza New York Style
Cassano's Pizza King
Locations in Fairfield, Monroe, Middletown, and Trenton
Cassano's Pizza King is more than just a local pizza shop, they are a cherished tradition that is deeply rooted in the heart of the community. Their commitment to crafting mouthwatering pizzas, subs, calzones, and pastas has remained unwavering.
Our Recommendation: Try one of their famous thin crust pizzas they are known for!
Chester’s Pizza
2929 Dixie Highway | Hamilton, OH
Photo Credit : Chester's Pizza
This is a family-owned pick up pizza joint, that has been passed down through generations. Known for their fresh ingredients and amazing taste, there is no need for them to stray away from their Mom’s original recipe. Whenever you are stopping by, you’ll get the same amazing taste we locals have all been talking about.
Our recommendation: Choose your own path! Pick your favorite toppings and go with it, you can't go wrong here.
Fairfield Pizza & Pasta
680 Nilles Road | Fairfield, OH
Photo Credit : Fairfield Pizza and Pasta
Serving up tavern style pizza: thinner & crunchier crust, square cut slices, and toppings from edge-to-edge, there is nothing better. With a menu with many different option, Fairfield Pizza is the perfect place for an outing with the family, even your pickiest eater can find something they’ll enjoy.
Our recommendation: Get one of their antipasto salads to start things off and order the Pepperoni Doubler: two layers of pepperoni and extra cheese.
Fratelli's Pizzeria
6890 Tylersville Road | West Chester, OH
Photo Credit : Fratelli's Pizzeria
Fratelli's is a family-owned business that is a staple for everyone in the area. They make their dough, sauces, and dressings from scratch every morning. With recipes that come from family members that live on the east coast with their own pizzerias, you will feel like you are in New York City. Right across the street from The Cone, this combo would make for the perfect night on the town.
Our Recommendation: The New Yorker - Pepperoni, Sausage, Onion, Green Peppers
The Hangry Hornet
17 American Way | Monroe, OH
The Hangry Hornet is a locally-owned pizza shop in Monroe that serves fresh pizzas, calzones, and subs to satisfy your taste buds.
Our Recommendation: Gluten Free Cauliflower pizza, topped with fresh lettuce, diced tomatoes, and crispy cauliflower crust.
Raymond's Pizza
Locations in Liberty Township and Fairfield Township
Raymond's Pizza honors the legacy of his grandfather by making great authentic pizza! From the homemade pizza dough to the signature pizza sauce made fresh from old family recipes, exceptional quality and taste can be found at Raymond's Pizza.
Our Recommendation: Build your own pizza with your choice of regular and premium toppings!
Richard’s Pizza
Locations in Fairfield, Hamilton, Monroe, and Trenton
Photo Credit : Richard's Pizza
This is a “have to” kind of place when visiting. Owner Richard Underwood opened his first location in 1955, where he created his famous pizza recipe that’s now a city staple. With 4 locations in Butler County, there is no way you can miss this chance. Richard’s is not just pizza, so don’t be afraid to branch out and order their Famous Italian Steak Sandwich, which can now be delivered nationwide.
Our Recommendation: Keep it simple with the pepperoni pizza, and for a sweet treat afterwards, make sure you grab some of their home made fudge.
Shaddock’s Pizza
4713 Central Avenue | Middletown, OH
Photo Credit : Shaddock's Pizza
Shaddock’s has been the place to go in Butler County for your crazier pizza wants for almost 60 years. Serving cold drinks, pizza, and subs since 1963, Shaddock’s is a Middletown tradition. Known for their thinner crispy crust pies, great service, and daily specials.
Our recommendation: Their famous Taco Pizza; salsa, cheese, onion, jalapeño, black olive, lettuce, tomato, and a side of sour cream
Two Cities Pizza
Located at The Pickle Lodge | West Chester, OH
Two Cities Pizza is a unique pizza shop that specializes in the different pizza styles from both New York and Chicago. They offer the perfect setting to fuel up for a pickleball match or watch the games nearby while enjoying your preferred choice of either deep-dish Chicago pizza, or the light and thinner New York style.
Our Recommendation: Whether you're a deep dish fan or thin crust is more your style, you can't go wrong with building your own custom pizza!
Victory Lane Pizza
638 S. Main Street | Monroe, OH
Pizza, breadsticks, salads, nachos, what more could you want! Victory Lane Pizza proudly serves delicious quality pizzas in Monroe.
Our Recommendation: Try their fan favorite Pickle Pizza, topped with dill pickles, a special dill sauce, and cheese!